Year Host School President's Trophy Winner
1963 Washington & Lee Washington (Mo.)
1964 Centre Washington (Mo.)
1965 Sewanee Washington (Mo.)
1966 Washington (Mo.) Washington (Mo.)
1967 Southwestern @ Memphis Southwestern @ Memphis
1968 Washington & Lee Washington & Lee
1969 Centre Washington & Lee
1970 Sewanee Washington (Mo.)
1971 Washington (Mo.) Washington (Mo.)
1972 Southwestern @ Memphis Washington & Lee
1973 Washington & Lee Washington & Lee
1974 Centre Sewanee
1975 Sewanee Rose-Hulman
1976 Southwestern @ Memphis Rose-Hulman / Sewanee (tie)
1977 Principia Centre
1978 Rose-Hulman Principia
1979 Sewanee Southwestern @ Memphis
1980 Centre Sewanee
1981 Southwestern @ Memphis Rose-Hulman
1982 Principia Rose-Hulman
1983 Rose-Hulman Rose-Hulman
1984 Centre Centre
1985 Sewanee Rose-Hulman
1986 Rhodes Rose-Hulman
1987 Earlham Rose-Hulman
1988 Rose-Hulman Rose-Hulman
1989 Sewanee Rose-Hulman
1990 Centre Centre
1991 Rhodes Centre

Year Host School President's Trophy Winner
1992 Millsaps Centre / Rhodes (tie)
1993 Trinity Rhodes
1994 Oglethorpe Trinity
1995 Hendrix Trinity
1996 Sewanee Trinity
1997 Southwestern Trinity
1998 Centre Trinity
1999 Trinity Trinity
2000 Rhodes Trinity
2001 DePauw DePauw
2002 Millsaps Trinity
2003 Rose-Hulman Trinity
2004 Oglethorpe Trinity
2005 Hendrix Trinity
2006 Sewanee DePauw
2007 Southwestern/Trinity DePauw
2008 Centre/DePauw